iPhone 15 Pro Max vs iPhone 17 Pro Max | TechTalkTown
iPhone 15 Pro Max vs iPhone 17 Pro Max
iPhone 15 Pro Max
Apple
8.8
Best iPhone of 2023, transformative titanium + 5x periscope + USB-C
iPhone 17 Pro Max
Apple
8.9
Apple's best Pro Max in years
iPhone 15 Pro Max
What Reviewers Agree On
Grade-5 titanium frame makes it ~20g lighter than the 14 Pro Max — most-praised in-hand feel of any iPhone yet (221g)
A17 Pro 3nm chip with hardware ray tracing — fastest mobile silicon at launch, future-proofs for Apple Intelligence on iOS 18
5x Tetraprism periscope telephoto (120mm) is Pro Max exclusive — first iPhone to break past 3x optical, with computational zoom to 25x
USB-C 3.0 finally arrives on iPhone (10Gbps on Pro/Max only — standard 15 caps at USB 2.0 speeds)
Customizable Action Button replaces the mute switch — opens camera, shortcut, focus mode, voice memo, magnifier and more
Pros & Cons
iPhone 15 Pro Max
Pros
Grade-5 titanium frame makes it ~20g lighter than the 14 Pro Max — most-praised in-hand feel of any iPhone yet (221g)
A17 Pro 3nm chip with hardware ray tracing — fastest mobile silicon at launch, future-proofs for Apple Intelligence on iOS 18
5x Tetraprism periscope telephoto (120mm) is Pro Max exclusive — first iPhone to break past 3x optical, with computational zoom to 25x
USB-C 3.0 finally arrives on iPhone (10Gbps on Pro/Max only — standard 15 caps at USB 2.0 speeds)
Customizable Action Button replaces the mute switch — opens camera, shortcut, focus mode, voice memo, magnifier and more
Detailed Comparison
Design & Build
iPhone 15 Pro Max
Grade-5 titanium frame drops weight ~20g to 221g — the headline change of the year. Slimmer bezels, contoured edges, USB-C port and customizable Action Button replace the mute switch. The most refined iPhone in-hand feel yet.
Grade-5 titanium frame replaces stainless steel — drops weight from 240g (14 Pro Max) to 221g (~20g lighter, ~10% lighter).
Slimmer bezels make the 6.7-inch display almost edge-to-edge; contoured edges with a slightly thicker frame around the back camera bump.
USB-C port replaces Lightning — Pro Max specifically gets USB-C 3.0 (10Gbps), enabling faster file transfers from connected SSDs/cameras.
TechTalkTown may earn a commission from purchases made through links below. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This does not influence our reviews. Learn more.
6.7" Super Retina XDR ProMotion 120Hz at 2000-nit peak — the best phone display Apple has shipped
USB-C 3.0 + Action Button + lighter titanium are the upgrades reviewers say justify the $1,199 price
6+ years of iOS updates — confirmed runway through iOS 23+ in 2030s
Deal Breakers
Launch overheating issues — A17 Pro ran hot in gaming and 4K shoots; iOS 17.0.3 mitigated but didn't fully eliminate it
Battery life regressed slightly vs the 14 Pro Max in several real-world tests — owners coming from older iPhones may notice the drop
$1,199 starting (256GB now base vs 128GB previously) is the most-expensive baseline iPhone Apple has shipped
Pro Max-exclusive 5x periscope means the Pro is stuck at 3x — those wanting compact + long zoom are out of luck
Notable owner complaints: titanium frame discolors with hand oils, the matte finish picks up fingerprints visibly
iPhone 17 Pro Max
What Reviewers Agree On
The 4,823 mAh battery and A19 Pro efficiency deliver the longest battery life ever on an iPhone — Apple's 39-hour video playback claim is backed up by record-setting lab measurements at Notebookcheck and Tom's Guide.
The new triple 48MP rear camera with the bigger telephoto sensor delivers a genuine improvement in 4x/8x reach and detail over the iPhone 16 Pro Max — the closest the iPhone has come to a Pixel/Samsung in flexible zoom.
The laser-welded vapor chamber and aluminum unibody noticeably reduce thermal throttling under sustained load — gaming and ProRes video recording stay cooler and frame-rate-stable far longer than on the iPhone 16 Pro.
The 6.9-inch ProMotion display hits 3,000 nits peak with a new anti-reflective coating, making it one of the easiest phones to read in direct sunlight even if Samsung's S25 Ultra still wins outright on glare.
The A19 Pro is the fastest chip Apple has shipped — 12GB of RAM up from 8GB, multi-core Geekbench around 9,500-9,994, and benchmark wins over the iPhone 16 Pro and Pixel 10 Pro XL.
Wired charging finally jumps to a real 40W (50% in 20 minutes with a 40W+ adapter) and wireless to 25W via the new Qi2 standard with built-in MagSafe magnets — the first time iPhone charging speed feels competitive.
The new 18MP Center Stage square selfie sensor is the most-praised camera feature of the generation — automatic portrait↔landscape switching, AI framing, and dual-capture all work as described.
Base storage doubles to 256GB at the same $1,199 starting price, with a new 2TB option exclusive to the Pro Max — high-time storage relief that Apple is finally not nickel-and-diming.
Deal Breakers
At 233 grams it is one of the heaviest non-folding flagships on the market and a step backward from the lighter titanium iPhone 15/16 Pro Max — Ars, Wired and 9to5Mac all flag the heft as the first thing you notice.
Aluminum is much softer than titanium or steel, and 'scratchgate' is real — independent iFixit testing confirmed anodization flakes on the camera-bump edges, and a vocal r/iphone contingent reports visible marks within weeks of caseless use.
Apple Intelligence is still essentially absent — reviewers from Wired, Trusted Reviews, TechCrunch, 9to5Mac and Reddit users all flag that Siri remains useless and the AI story is a generation behind Gemini and Galaxy AI.
The two-tone aluminum-and-glass design with visible camera-cutout seams is divisive — Ars Technica, Forbes commenters, and an r/gadgets thread all call the back 'unfinished-looking,' 'lumpy,' or 'not Jony Ive's iPhone' design language.
The 'optical-quality' 8x zoom is actually a digital crop of the 4x 48MP sensor, not true periscope optics — Vivo, Xiaomi, Honor and the Pixel 10 Pro XL still capture more detail at long range with real periscope hardware.
6.7" Super Retina XDR ProMotion 120Hz at 2000-nit peak — the best phone display Apple has shipped
USB-C 3.0 + Action Button + lighter titanium are the upgrades reviewers say justify the $1,199 price
6+ years of iOS updates — confirmed runway through iOS 23+ in 2030s
Cons
Launch overheating issues — A17 Pro ran hot in gaming and 4K shoots; iOS 17.0.3 mitigated but didn't fully eliminate it
Battery life regressed slightly vs the 14 Pro Max in several real-world tests — owners coming from older iPhones may notice the drop
$1,199 starting (256GB now base vs 128GB previously) is the most-expensive baseline iPhone Apple has shipped
Pro Max-exclusive 5x periscope means the Pro is stuck at 3x — those wanting compact + long zoom are out of luck
Notable owner complaints: titanium frame discolors with hand oils, the matte finish picks up fingerprints visibly
iPhone 17 Pro Max
Pros
The 4,823 mAh battery and A19 Pro efficiency deliver the longest battery life ever on an iPhone — Apple's 39-hour video playback claim is backed up by record-setting lab measurements at Notebookcheck and Tom's Guide.
The new triple 48MP rear camera with the bigger telephoto sensor delivers a genuine improvement in 4x/8x reach and detail over the iPhone 16 Pro Max — the closest the iPhone has come to a Pixel/Samsung in flexible zoom.
The laser-welded vapor chamber and aluminum unibody noticeably reduce thermal throttling under sustained load — gaming and ProRes video recording stay cooler and frame-rate-stable far longer than on the iPhone 16 Pro.
The 6.9-inch ProMotion display hits 3,000 nits peak with a new anti-reflective coating, making it one of the easiest phones to read in direct sunlight even if Samsung's S25 Ultra still wins outright on glare.
The A19 Pro is the fastest chip Apple has shipped — 12GB of RAM up from 8GB, multi-core Geekbench around 9,500-9,994, and benchmark wins over the iPhone 16 Pro and Pixel 10 Pro XL.
Wired charging finally jumps to a real 40W (50% in 20 minutes with a 40W+ adapter) and wireless to 25W via the new Qi2 standard with built-in MagSafe magnets — the first time iPhone charging speed feels competitive.
The new 18MP Center Stage square selfie sensor is the most-praised camera feature of the generation — automatic portrait↔landscape switching, AI framing, and dual-capture all work as described.
Base storage doubles to 256GB at the same $1,199 starting price, with a new 2TB option exclusive to the Pro Max — high-time storage relief that Apple is finally not nickel-and-diming.
Cons
At 233 grams it is one of the heaviest non-folding flagships on the market and a step backward from the lighter titanium iPhone 15/16 Pro Max — Ars, Wired and 9to5Mac all flag the heft as the first thing you notice.
Aluminum is much softer than titanium or steel, and 'scratchgate' is real — independent iFixit testing confirmed anodization flakes on the camera-bump edges, and a vocal r/iphone contingent reports visible marks within weeks of caseless use.
Apple Intelligence is still essentially absent — reviewers from Wired, Trusted Reviews, TechCrunch, 9to5Mac and Reddit users all flag that Siri remains useless and the AI story is a generation behind Gemini and Galaxy AI.
The two-tone aluminum-and-glass design with visible camera-cutout seams is divisive — Ars Technica, Forbes commenters, and an r/gadgets thread all call the back 'unfinished-looking,' 'lumpy,' or 'not Jony Ive's iPhone' design language.
Owner concern: titanium frame discolors visibly from hand oils, the matte finish picks up fingerprints quickly — Apple advised wiping with a microfiber cloth.
IP68 water/dust resistance carries over from the 14 Pro Max — fully splash/water resistant.
iPhone 17 Pro Max
Apple swapped titanium for a heat-forged 7000-series aluminum unibody, added Ceramic Shield 2 on the front, and stretched the camera bump into a full-width 'plateau.' The two-tone back with its glass MagSafe cutout splits reviewers — some celebrate the function-over-form pivot, others find the design unfinished, the 233g weight unwelcome, and the soft aluminum vulnerable to scratching ('scratchgate'). Cosmic Orange is the headline color and a real departure from years of muted Pro tones.
Apple has gone full function over form with the iPhone 17 Pro — chunky utilitarian phones that prioritize cooling, battery and durability over the slim premium feel of the iPhone 16 Pro.
The two-tone aluminum-and-glass design looks unfinished and prototype-y — the cell-signal cutouts and the glass MagSafe panel are clearly forced by physics rather than design choices.
The new Camera Plateau and two-tone aluminum-glass back add visual character — and the camera bar finally stops the phone wobbling on a table the way every previous iPhone did.
At 233 grams the Pro Max is chunky and heavy — picking it up after the iPhone Air I yelled 'Holy crap,' and you'll definitely notice the heft coming from a 15 or 16 Pro Max.
The aluminum unibody felt sturdy and scratch-resistant in two weeks of caseless use — even tossed into a bag with keys, badges and other phones, neither the Pro nor the Pro Max picked up a single scratch.
'Scratchgate' is real — independent iFixit testing confirmed the anodization process Apple uses is more susceptible to scratching and flaking on non-flat surfaces like the camera-bump edges.
A part of the premium look and feel is lost — the new design has visible gaps between the aluminum and glass parts, and the soft aluminum compromises drop and scratch resistance versus titanium or steel.
Apple's two-tone design adds character — the Camera Plateau gives the phone a more balanced look in hand, even if Google's Pixel did the cross-back camera bar first.
The iPhone 17 Pro is the most fully featured Pro model yet — not the best-looking Pro, but the trade-off for substance over style is genuinely worth it.
r/gadgets pulled no punches — the dominant view is that the iPhone 17 Pro is 'the most Un-Jony Ive iPhones Apple has ever made,' with the camera plateau called 'pretty ugly' and 'a nothing.'
Display
iPhone 15 Pro Max
6.7-inch Super Retina XDR OLED with ProMotion 120Hz adaptive refresh and a 2000-nit peak brightness — the best display Apple has shipped. Dynamic Island carries over from the 14 Pro Max with no major changes.
6.7-inch Super Retina XDR OLED, 2796×1290, ProMotion 120Hz adaptive (1-120Hz), 2000-nit peak HDR — best iPhone display ever shipped.
Display brightness easily readable in direct sunlight — meaningful improvement over the 14 Pro Max's 1600-nit peak.
Dynamic Island carries over from 14 Pro Max with no major feature changes — still the iPhone's most distinctive UI element.
ProMotion 120Hz on the Pro is 'significantly smoother' than the standard iPhone 15's locked 60Hz — a real-world differentiator.
iPhone 17 Pro Max
The 6.9-inch LTPO Super Retina XDR OLED carries over from the 16 Pro Max but gains Ceramic Shield 2 (Apple claims 3x better scratch resistance), a seven-layer anti-reflective coating, and a peak brightness boost from 2,000 to 3,000 nits in sunlight. Nearly every reviewer rates it among the best smartphone displays sold today, with Samsung's S25 Ultra still winning on outright anti-glare and a minority noting that auto-brightness rarely sustains the full peak.
The 3,000-nit peak brightness and anti-reflective coating make the iPhone 17 Pro Max easier to read in direct sunlight than its predecessor, with significantly less indoor glare from artificial light.
The screen has the new Ceramic Shield 2 with anti-reflective coating for 'incredible legibility' in challenging lighting conditions, though Apple still owes its biggest scratch resistance claims to a stretch.
There is still much more glare on the iPhone 17 Pro Max than on the Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra's Gorilla Armor 2 panel — Apple has improved it, but the S25 Ultra still wins outright.
The iPhone 17 Pro Max display stays brilliant and vibrant even under harsh California sun — it gets noticeably brighter than the iPhone Air's screen at maximum brightness.
The 6.9-inch ProMotion screen is exactly the same panel as last year's Pro Max — same size, same resolution, just slightly narrower bezels and the brightness/anti-reflective upgrades.
Value vs Competition
iPhone 15 Pro Max
$1,199 starting (256GB base) — the most-expensive baseline iPhone yet. In 2026 it's the smart-buy Apple pick at $700-900 used with 6+ years of updates left. Versus the S23 Ultra: closer than ever on cameras + zoom, still loses on raw zoom range.
Launched at $1,199 with 256GB base storage (vs $1,099/128GB on the 14 Pro Max) — meaningful real-cost increase even with the storage doubling.
Best smartphone deal in 2025: at $700-900 used the iPhone 15 Pro Max delivers titanium + USB-C 3.0 + 5x periscope + A17 Pro + 6 more years of updates.
Phone Arena: 'the best phone I've ever owned to date' — long-term verdict after months of use.
vs Galaxy S23 Ultra ($1,199): Apple wins on natural color/video/USB-C 3.0/longevity; Samsung wins on 10x periscope and S Pen.
Best for: existing Apple users on iPhone 12/13 wanting USB-C + titanium + 5x zoom; long-time Pro Max users get meaningful gains too.
iPhone 17 Pro Max
At $1,199 starting (256GB up from 128GB at the same nominal price) the Pro Max is $100 cheaper than the Galaxy S26 Ultra and roughly matches the Pixel 10 Pro XL. Reviewers split on whether the year-over-year jump justifies upgrading from a 15/16 Pro Max — TechCrunch and Tom's Guide say no, the gains aren't compelling; Trusted Reviews, Forbes and Notebookcheck say the cooling + camera + battery combination is the most worthwhile Pro upgrade in years. The hardware is widely called Apple's best Pro Max in years; the software story (iOS 26 bugs, weak Apple Intelligence) is the consistent caveat. Anyone older than a 14 Pro Max will see substantial gains across the board.
The iPhone 17 Pro Max is the phone to get if you love iOS and want a big screen and the longest battery life possible — but it's hard to recommend upgrading from a 15 Pro Max or 16 Pro Max because the enhancements aren't compelling enough.
If you have an iPhone 15 Pro or 16 Pro Max, the iPhone 17 Pro Max is more of an iterative update — but if your phone is more than two years old you'll see substantial gains in battery, performance, screen and camera.
The Pro iPhones this year are the best and most capable iPhone hardware Apple has released in a few years — even relative to the best Android phones, the gap has closed dramatically.
Reception-quality issues with the new N1 wireless chip — Reddit r/apple and r/iphone owners report Bluetooth audio dropouts in cars and AirPods Pro 3 disconnects that didn't happen on the iPhone 16 Pro Max.
The 'optical-quality' 8x zoom is actually a digital crop of the 4x 48MP sensor, not true periscope optics — Vivo, Xiaomi, Honor and the Pixel 10 Pro XL still capture more detail at long range with real periscope hardware.
Reception-quality issues with the new N1 wireless chip — Reddit r/apple and r/iphone owners report Bluetooth audio dropouts in cars and AirPods Pro 3 disconnects that didn't happen on the iPhone 16 Pro Max.
The new screen on iPhone 17 Pro is great whether you choose the 6.3-inch or 6.9-inch panel — it's one of the best phone screens around with HDR, 120Hz ProMotion and always-on.
Liquid Glass animations on iOS 26 can be inconsistently applied and broken on the Pro Max — a shame because the underlying design is actually a step forward.
The iPhone 17 Pro Max sets the benchmark in the Apple universe — the largest display, biggest battery, longest endurance, highest performance, and up to 2 TB of storage, and the base price didn't go up despite doubling base storage to 256GB.
If you're already in the Apple ecosystem, shoot video seriously, or just want a phone that does its job without much thought, the iPhone 17 Pro Max makes a stronger case versus the Galaxy S26 Ultra than any recent iPhone has.
The Pro Max is for people whose phones are their most important camera, or for people who want the biggest screen — for everyone else, the regular iPhone 17 with the same display panel is the one to get for $300 less.
It's the most enticing Pro iPhone in years — Apple finally moved on substance over thinness, and the camera + battery + cooling combination makes this the most worthwhile Pro upgrade since the iPhone 11 Pro.
r/iphone owners are split — half say the Pro Max is the best iPhone they've ever owned, half say it's a software-ruined letdown despite great hardware.
r/apple consensus on the Dave2D review thread skews strongly positive — '12 GB of RAM and 5000 mAh battery on the max completely SLAPS,' and the practical hardware improvements over the 16 Pro Max are widely appreciated even among the design skeptics.
